Tags: journalism



Press Release
by the Independent Mass Media Union, Kyiv branch


Eleven deputies of the Parliament have registered a law project "About the amendments to be introduced into the Code of Criminal Procedure of Ukraine * [see Note 1 below] - about the journalists' rights to protect the sources of their information"


The law project adds the profession of journalism to the list of those occupations that are exempt from the regular police interrogations about the contents of knowledge conferred to them by their clientele during the course of their work. This list now includes the notaries, the medical professionals, including psychologists, and the servitors of religious cults.

The project limits the right to make decisions to initiate the police searches and seizures of a journalist's equipment to some competent authorities, namely, the Judges on the level of the District Courts of Appeal, whose mandates must be motivated on the basis of requests by the District Public Prosecutors, who ought not fail to specifically mention that the search would be conducted at a journalist's premises.

This initiative is a practical result ot the Round Table conference "The Journalists and the Police: how to avoid confrontations?", which was held by the activists of the Independent Mass Media Union, Kyiv branch, and the journalists from the Information Agency "At Your Side", with the help of "InterNews". The technical details were worked out by a legal specialist Mr. Roman Holovenko from the Mass Media Institute, and by a member of the management of the Mass Media Union, Kyiv branch, Mr. Yuri Shelazhenko.

"At the present time, journalists are not protected from a police pressure tactics, even though there exist the legal norms about the protection of the sources of information. This happens because the Police relies on a narrow interpretation of
the Code of Criminal Procedure of Ukraine * [see Note 1 below], wherein there is no mention of any such norm. The reality has lately furnished a sad example - the search and seizure of equipment of Ms. Olena Bilozerska, a professional journalist, - testified the Manager of the Independent Mass Media Union, Kyiv branch, Mr. Yuri Likanov.

The principal editor of the Information Agency "At Your Side", Ms. Olena Bilozerska has also made a direct contribution to the development of the Project of Law. "We do not intend to create a privileged citizen's category for the journalists, we insist only on the defense of the professional prerogatives, required for a successful accomplishment of our tasks. By the nature of the profession, journalists may find themselves in the possession of some confidential information. If its sources were not protected, it would be impossible to assure any future cooperation from informants", - explained Olena Bilozerska.

The Independent Mass Media Union appeals to all the deputies of the Parliament to support the Project of the Law, and expresses its gratitude to the eleven deputies * [see Note 2], at whose initiative the project was registered.

Note 1.
According to the legal tradition and the legislation of Ukraine, the Rules of Criminal Procedure constitute a Codex in its own right, parallel to the Criminal Code, and is therefore found under the jurisdiction of the Parliament - which is unlike the American tradition, wherein the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure are traditionally a direct part of the responsibility of the Judicial branch of Government, up to the Supreme Court. In other words, it is the Courts, who establish, and modify, if necessary, under the pressure of case law, the current rules.
It is also unlike the Canadian system, wherein the Criminal Code is found under the responsibility of the Federal Government, but its implementation in practice is given to the competence of the Provincial Governments; thus, for instance, in Québec, - Le Code de procédure pénale.

Note 2. The names of all eleven members of the Parliament, at whose initiative the Law Project has been registered, are given in the Ukrainian text version of this Press Release, see:


“The Journalists and The Police: how to avoid confrontations?”

The journalist's initiative on the changes to be introduced into the Criminal Code

A Round Table Conference in Kyiv on the subject “The Journalists and The Police: how to avoid confrontations?”

On the premises of “InterNews-Ukraine” on March 1st, 2011 there was held a Round Table Conference on the subject of avoiding confrontations between the Police and The Journalists.

Its organizers were The Independent Union of Mass Media, Kyiv branch, headed by its Chairman Yury Lukanov, the moderator of the event Andrew Yanicky, the “InterNews-Ukraine”, and the Information Agency “At Your Side”, run by Bilozerska and Yaroslavtsev.

There were more than 30 participants at the Round Table – journalists, jurists who work with the Mass Media, the representative of the Ministry of Internal Affairs (that is, the Police), some public figures who are active in the field of human rights, and three Deputies of the Parliament, namely, Mrs. Lesia Orobets, Mr. Andrew Pavlovsky, and Mr.Andrew Parubiy.

Collapse )

We are planning a Round Table on the subject "Journalists and the Police"

Posted in Ukrainian on 2011.02.14 at 17:49

We are planing a Round Table with a projected name "Journalists and the Law Enforcing Authorities", tentatively set for March 1st, 2011. "We" includes The Independent Media Content Contributors Union in Kyiv, Civil Society Group "Internews Ukraine", and the Information Agency "At Your Side". The idea comes from my partner in this Information Agency, Alek Yaroslavtsev.

Below I will outline the plans of the conference, on the basis of our discussions with Andrew Yanicky from the Kyiv Union of the Independent Media Content Contributors, and of my own reflections.

First of all, as to the participants: we intend to invite all journalists, the victims of illegal Police actions - the more, the better. By now I already have an approximate list, with some contact information. Nevertheless - I invite the participation of all and any journalists, who feel that they were subjected to an abuse by the Police. I appeal as well to anybody with a knowledge of such events, to submit the descriptions of them here in the comments section, while naming those involved.

We are also inviting, other than the journalists, the Deputies of the Parliament (and not only from the Opposition), the lawyers working in the media environment, and all those public figures with the interest in this issue. With many of these I am acquainted and I will invite them. All the same - I welcome all suggestions about the names of those who merit to be present at this conference, so that I could take care of the invitations.

Format: I wouldn't like the discourses with statistics. From this sin usually suffer the representatives of the Law Enforcement field, who delight in quoting some numbers that paint such an optimistic picture - which does not quite jibe with the sad realities. Therefore - give us less numbers, and more specifics instead, please.

The purpose: to arrive somewhere other than at a non consequential exchange of opinions.
Some points to cover:

1.The existing legislation is being ignored. The only effective defense against abuse, even in situations foreseen by the Laws, is by creating a lot of noise around the problem. But even then the maximum achievable result seems to be that a victim is left in peace. Those guilty of abuse and non-respect of the Law are never punished, which leads to the repetition of offenses.

Collapse )